The work permit journey in America is one I had known and endured for a long time. The news that came over the weekend about the $100K fee got me thinking like many others, about what this means for expat Indian professionals and their families. Former NITI Aayog CEO Amitabh Kant reacted by suggesting that the policy, which restricts global talent from entering the US, would stifle American innovation but benefit India. According to Kant, the restrictive measure creates an opportunity for India’s top engineers, doctors, scientists, and innovators to fuel growth and innovation within Indian tech hubs such as Bangalore, Hyderabad, Pune, and Gurgaon.
Kant believes that with the US “slamming the door” on foreign talent, the next wave of research labs, patents, startups, and technological advancements will be centered in India’s rapidly growing urban technology centers. Global tech giants who already have a strong presence in these cities could see a surge in local talent and innovation as highly skilled professionals opt to stay in or return to India rather than pay the exorbitant visa fee or face uncertainty in the US market.
This would be absolutely wonderful if tethered to reality for anyone who is adversely impacted by the policy. I did return to India as a single mom decades ago and tried my very best to make it work for me and J. I had the unwavering support of my parents and was fortunate to find a job in large global company in the midst of the dotcom bust. Considering my circumstances, I could not have been luckier. Notwithstanding, I was not able to last more than a year. Life on work visa in America was extremely complicated and catastrophically limiting for my career given my responsibilities as a single mother. I endured it lacking better options, specially back home in India.
If even a small part of Kant's claims were true back in the day, I would have stayed in the country of my birth at least until I had recovered from the most bruising event of my life. I simply could not for more reasons than I can count. This is the reality I have known and lived. To this day, young people seek any and all options outside India because what is on offer at home does feel enough in any dimension. Kant talks a big game that aims to appeal to "patriotism" and "duty" without real value for the person who is being asked to make many great things happen in India. The message is that America is clearly rejecting you so stop complaining, come home, and brace to fight the ceaseless uphill battles that it takes to survive.
Starting from approximately the same place several decades ago, China has rapidly developed a world-class ecosystem for high-level employment in technology, research, and manufacturing, investing heavily in STEM education, modern infrastructure, and innovation hubs that support large-scale domestic job creation for millions of graduates. Major cities such as Beijing, Shenzhen, and Shanghai rival global tech capitals, with local firms offering competitive salaries, advanced research opportunities, and robust career advancement, ensuring that Chinese talent has significant incentive to remain and thrive within the country. Government policies, including STEM-targeted “K” visas and expansive funding, further consolidate China’s reputation as a top destination for both domestic and international skilled workers.
Conversely, while India produces massive numbers of STEM graduates, its domestic job market remains less developed, with limited high-end opportunities concentrated in IT services and a continued reliance on global outsourcing. India’s skilled workforce often seeks opportunities abroad due to underemployment, skills mismatch, and slower growth in advanced manufacturing and research sectors within the country. Despite national initiatives aiming to strengthen local industries, India’s diaspora continues to power global tech economies, contrasting sharply with China’s increasing success in retaining and engaging its own top talent domestically.
All that said, this bit of wisdom from someone on LinkedIn is more useful - instead of paying an US university, fund your kid's startup dream. The comments show that skepticism abounds if this will really make India the startup capital of the world. It most certainly is not for the lack of talent or effort of the people which has always been abundant. It's just everything else.